diff --git a/server/notifications/queues/appQueue.js b/server/notifications/queues/appQueue.js
index 1f198698c..b376b2cf6 100644
--- a/server/notifications/queues/appQueue.js
+++ b/server/notifications/queues/appQueue.js
@@ -92,7 +92,7 @@ const loadAppQueue = async ({ pubClient, logger, redisHelpers, ioRedis }) => {
             "consolidate-notifications",
             { jobId, recipients },
             {
-              jobId: `consolidate:${jobId}`,
+              jobId: `consolidate-${jobId}`,
               delay: APP_CONSOLIDATION_DELAY,
               attempts: 3,
               backoff: LOCK_EXPIRATION
@@ -288,7 +288,7 @@ const dispatchAppsToQueue = async ({ appsToDispatch }) => {
     await appQueue.add(
       "add-notification",
       { jobId, bodyShopId, key, variables, recipients, body, jobRoNumber },
-      { jobId: `${jobId}:${Date.now()}` }
+      { jobId: `${jobId}-${Date.now()}` }
     );
     devDebugLogger(`Added notification to queue for jobId ${jobId} with ${recipients.length} recipients`);
   }
diff --git a/server/notifications/queues/emailQueue.js b/server/notifications/queues/emailQueue.js
index 7d965cb69..a5ad8a530 100644
--- a/server/notifications/queues/emailQueue.js
+++ b/server/notifications/queues/emailQueue.js
@@ -86,7 +86,7 @@ const loadEmailQueue = async ({ pubClient, logger }) => {
             "consolidate-emails",
             { jobId, jobRoNumber, bodyShopName, bodyShopTimezone },
             {
-              jobId: `consolidate:${jobId}`,
+              jobId: `consolidate-${jobId}`,
               delay: EMAIL_CONSOLIDATION_DELAY,
               attempts: 3,
               backoff: LOCK_EXPIRATION
@@ -252,7 +252,7 @@ const dispatchEmailsToQueue = async ({ emailsToDispatch, logger }) => {
     await emailAddQueue.add(
       "add-email-notification",
       { jobId, jobRoNumber, bodyShopName, bodyShopTimezone, body, recipients },
-      { jobId: `${jobId}:${Date.now()}` }
+      { jobId: `${jobId}-${Date.now()}` }
     );
     devDebugLogger(`Added email notification to queue for jobId ${jobId} with ${recipients.length} recipients`);
   }