IO-1366 Refine audit trail detail logging

client/src/components/bill-detail-edit/bill-detail-edit-component.jsx

@@ -13,6 +13,7 @@ import { insertAuditTrail } from "../../redux/application/application.actions";
 import { selectBodyshop } from "../../redux/user/user.selectors";
 import AuditTrailMapping from "../../utils/AuditTrailMappings";
 import dayjs from "../../utils/day";
+import { buildBillUpdateAuditDetails } from "../../utils/auditTrailDetails";
 import AlertComponent from "../alert/alert.component";
 import BillFormContainer from "../bill-form/bill-form.container";
 import BillMarkExportedButton from "../bill-mark-exported-button/bill-mark-exported-button.component";
@@ -134,96 +135,17 @@ export function BillDetailEditcontainer({ insertAuditTrail, bodyshop }) {
 
     await Promise.all(updates);
 
-    const details = (() => {
+    const details = buildBillUpdateAuditDetails({
-      const original = data?.bills_by_pk ?? {};
+      originalBill: data?.bills_by_pk,
-      const updated = { ...bill, billlines };
+      bill,
-
+      billlines
-      const fmtVal = (key, val) =>
+    });
-        val == null || val === ""
-          ? "<<empty>>"
-          : typeof val === "number" && key.toLowerCase().includes("price")
-            ? `$${val.toFixed(2)}`
-            : val;
-
-      const keysToTrack = ["line_desc", "quantity", "actual_price", "actual_cost", "cost_center"];
-      const lineVals = (obj) => keysToTrack.map((k) => fmtVal(k, obj[k])).join(", ");
-
-      const changed = Object.entries(updated)
-        .filter(([k, v]) => v != null && v !== "" && k !== "billlines" && k !== "__typename")
-        .map(([k, v]) => {
-          const orig = original[k];
-          if (k === "date") {
-            const a = orig ? dayjs(orig) : null;
-            const b = v ? (dayjs.isDayjs(v) ? v : dayjs(v)) : null;
-            return (a && b && a.isSame(b, "day")) || (!a && !b)
-              ? null
-              : `date: ${a?.format("YYYY-MM-DD") ?? "<<empty>>"} → ${b?.format("YYYY-MM-DD") ?? "<<empty>>"}`;
-          }
-          return typeof orig === "object" || typeof v === "object" || String(orig) === String(v)
-            ? null
-            : `${k}: ${fmtVal(k, orig)} → ${fmtVal(k, v)}`;
-        })
-        .filter(Boolean);
-
-      const origLines = original.billlines ?? [];
-      const updLines = updated.billlines ?? [];
-
-      const addedObjs = updLines
-        .filter((l) => !l.id)
-        .map((u) => ({ label: u.line_desc || u.description || "new line", vals: lineVals(u), handled: false }));
-
-      const removedObjs = origLines
-        .filter((o) => !updLines.some((u) => u.id === o.id))
-        .map((o) => ({
-          label: o.line_desc || o.description || o.id || "removed line",
-          vals: lineVals(o),
-          handled: false
-        }));
-
-      const labelToAdded = addedObjs.reduce((m, a) => m.set(a.label, [...(m.get(a.label) ?? []), a]), new Map());
-
-      const modified = [
-        ...removedObjs.reduce((acc, r) => {
-          const candidates = labelToAdded.get(r.label) ?? [];
-          const exact = candidates.find((c) => c.vals === r.vals && !c.handled);
-          if (exact) {
-            exact.handled = r.handled = true;
-            return acc;
-          } // identical → cancel out
-          const diff = candidates.find((c) => c.vals !== r.vals && !c.handled);
-          if (diff) {
-            diff.handled = r.handled = true;
-            acc.push(`${r.label}: ${r.vals} → ${diff.vals}`);
-          }
-          return acc;
-        }, []),
-        ...updLines
-          .filter((u) => u.id)
-          .flatMap((u) => {
-            const o = origLines.find((x) => x.id === u.id);
-            if (!o) return [];
-            const diffs = keysToTrack
-              .filter((k) => String(o[k]) !== String(u[k]))
-              .map((k) => `${fmtVal(k, o[k])} → ${fmtVal(k, u[k])}`);
-            return diffs.length ? [`${u.line_desc || u.description || u.id}: ${diffs.join("; ")}`] : [];
-          })
-      ];
-
-      [
-        ["added", addedObjs.filter((a) => !a.handled).map((a) => `+${a.label} (${a.vals})`)],
-        ["removed", removedObjs.filter((r) => !r.handled).map((r) => `-${r.label} (${r.vals})`)],
-        ["modified", modified]
-      ].forEach(([type, items]) => {
-        if (items.length) changed.push(`billlines ${type}: ${items.join(" | ")}`);
-      });
-
-      return changed.length ? changed.join("; ") : bill.invoice_number || "No changes";
-    })();
 
     insertAuditTrail({
-      jobid: bill.jobid,
+      jobid: bill.jobid ?? data?.bills_by_pk?.jobid,
       billid: search.billid,
-      operation: AuditTrailMapping.billupdated(bill.invoice_number, details)
+      operation: AuditTrailMapping.billupdated(bill.invoice_number, details),
+      type: "billupdated"
     });
 
     await refetch();

client/src/components/job-lines-upsert-modal/job-lines-upsert-modal.container.jsx

@@ -16,6 +16,7 @@ import JobLinesUpdsertModal from "./job-lines-upsert-modal.component";
 import { useNotification } from "../../contexts/Notifications/notificationContext.jsx";
 import AuditTrailMapping from "../../utils/AuditTrailMappings.js";
 import { insertAuditTrail } from "../../redux/application/application.actions.js";
+import { buildJobLineInsertAuditDetails, buildJobLineUpdateAuditDetails } from "../../utils/auditTrailDetails.js";
 
 const mapStateToProps = createStructuredSelector({
   jobLineEditModal: selectJobLineEditModal,
@@ -79,12 +80,7 @@ function JobLinesUpsertModalContainer({ jobLineEditModal, toggleModalVisible, bo
         });
         insertAuditTrail({
           jobid: jobLineEditModal.context.jobid,
-          operation: AuditTrailMapping.jobmanuallineinsert(
+          operation: AuditTrailMapping.jobmanuallineinsert(buildJobLineInsertAuditDetails(values)),
-            Object.entries(values)
-              .filter(([k, v]) => v != null && v !== "" && k !== "ah_detail_line" && k !== "prt_dsmk_p")
-              .map(([k, v]) => `${k}: ${v}`)
-              .join("; ")
-          ),
           type: "jobmanuallineinsert"
         });
       } else {
@@ -119,23 +115,11 @@ function JobLinesUpsertModalContainer({ jobLineEditModal, toggleModalVisible, bo
         insertAuditTrail({
           jobid: jobLineEditModal.context.jobid,
           operation: AuditTrailMapping.joblineupdate(
-            (() => {
+            values.line_desc || jobLineEditModal.context.line_desc || "manual line",
-              const original = jobLineEditModal.context || {};
+            buildJobLineUpdateAuditDetails({
-              const changed = Object.entries(values)
+              originalLine: jobLineEditModal.context,
-                .filter(([k, v]) => v != null && v !== "" && k !== "ah_detail_line" && k !== "prt_dsmk_p")
+              values
-                .map(([k, v]) => {
+            })
-                  const orig = original[k];
-                  if (String(orig) === String(v)) return null;
-                  const fmt = (key, val) => {
-                    if (val == null || val === "") return "<<empty>>";
-                    if (typeof val === "number" && key.toLowerCase().includes("price")) return `$${val.toFixed(2)}`;
-                    return val;
-                  };
-                  return `${k}: ${fmt(k, orig)} → ${fmt(k, v)}`;
-                })
-                .filter(Boolean);
-              return changed.length ? changed.join("; ") : "No changes";
-            })()
           ),
           type: "joblineupdate"
         });

client/src/components/time-ticket-modal/time-ticket-modal.container.jsx

@@ -17,6 +17,7 @@ import TimeTicketsCommitToggleComponent from "../time-tickets-commit-toggle/time
 import TimeTicketModalComponent from "./time-ticket-modal.component";
 import { insertAuditTrail } from "../../redux/application/application.actions.js";
 import AuditTrailMapping from "../../utils/AuditTrailMappings";
+import { buildTimeTicketAuditSummary } from "../../utils/auditTrailDetails.js";
 
 const mapStateToProps = createStructuredSelector({
   timeTicketModal: selectTimeTicket,
@@ -53,87 +54,77 @@ export function TimeTicketModalContainer({ timeTicketModal, toggleModalVisible,
     fetchPolicy: "network-only",
     nextFetchPolicy: "network-only"
   });
+  const employees = EmployeeAutoCompleteData?.employees ?? [];
 
   const handleFinish = (values) => {
-    // Save submitted values so we can compute audit-trail details after the mutation completes
     lastSubmittedRef.current = values;
     setLoading(true);
-    const emps = EmployeeAutoCompleteData?.employees.filter((e) => e.id === values.employeeid);
+    const isEdit = Boolean(timeTicketModal.context.id);
-    if (timeTicketModal.context.id) {
+    const emps = employees.filter((employee) => employee.id === values.employeeid);
-      updateTicket({
+    const mutation = isEdit
-        variables: {
+      ? updateTicket({
-          timeticketId: timeTicketModal.context.id,
+          variables: {
-          timeticket: {
+            timeticketId: timeTicketModal.context.id,
-            ...values,
+            timeticket: {
-            rate: emps.length === 1 ? emps[0].rates.filter((r) => r.cost_center === values.cost_center)[0]?.rate : null
-          }
-        }
-      })
-        .then(handleMutationSuccess)
-        .catch(handleMutationError);
-    } else {
-      //Get selected employee rate.
-      insertTicket({
-        variables: {
-          timeTicketInput: [
-            {
               ...values,
               rate:
-                emps.length === 1 ? emps[0].rates.filter((r) => r.cost_center === values.cost_center)[0].rate : null,
+                emps.length === 1 ? emps[0].rates.filter((r) => r.cost_center === values.cost_center)[0]?.rate : null
-              bodyshopid: bodyshop.id,
-              created_by: timeTicketModal.context.created_by
             }
-          ]
+          }
-        }
+        })
-      })
+      : insertTicket({
-        .then(handleMutationSuccess)
+          variables: {
-        .catch(handleMutationError);
+            timeTicketInput: [
-    }
+              {
+                ...values,
+                rate:
+                  emps.length === 1 ? emps[0].rates.filter((r) => r.cost_center === values.cost_center)[0].rate : null,
+                bodyshopid: bodyshop.id,
+                created_by: timeTicketModal.context.created_by
+              }
+            ]
+          }
+        });
+
+    mutation.then((result) => handleMutationSuccess(result, isEdit)).catch(handleMutationError);
   };
 
-  const handleMutationSuccess = () => {
+  const handleMutationSuccess = (result, isEdit) => {
     notification.success({
       title: t("timetickets.successes.created")
     });
 
-    const timeticket = timeTicketModal.context?.timeticket ?? {};
+    const savedTicket =
-    const original = timeticket || {};
+      result?.data?.update_timetickets?.returning?.[0] ?? result?.data?.insert_timetickets?.returning?.[0] ?? {};
-    const submitted = lastSubmittedRef.current || {};
+    const originalTicket = timeTicketModal.context?.timeticket ?? {};
-
+    const submittedValues = {
-    const fmt = (key, val) => {
+      ...(lastSubmittedRef.current ?? {}),
-      if (val == null || val === "") return "<<empty>>";
+      date: lastSubmittedRef.current?.date ?? savedTicket.date ?? originalTicket.date ?? null,
-      const k = key.toLowerCase();
+      employeeid: lastSubmittedRef.current?.employeeid ?? savedTicket.employeeid ?? originalTicket.employeeid ?? null,
-      if (dayjs.isDayjs?.(val)) return dayjs(val).format(k.includes("clock") ? "YYYY-MM-DD HH:mm" : "YYYY-MM-DD");
+      jobid:
-      if (typeof val === "number")
+        lastSubmittedRef.current?.jobid ??
-        return k.includes("hrs")
+        savedTicket.jobid ??
-          ? val.toFixed(1)
+        timeTicketModal.context.jobId ??
-          : k.includes("rate") || k.includes("price")
+        originalTicket.job?.id ??
-            ? `$${val.toFixed(2)}`
+        originalTicket.jobid ??
-            : String(val);
+        null
-      if (key === "employeeid") {
-        const emp = EmployeeAutoCompleteData?.employees?.find(({ id }) => id === val);
-        return emp ? `${emp.first_name} ${emp.last_name}` : String(val);
-      }
-      return String(val);
     };
-
+    const auditSummary = buildTimeTicketAuditSummary({
-    const changed = Object.entries(submitted)
+      originalTicket,
-      .filter(([, v]) => v != null && v !== "")
+      submittedValues,
-      .map(([k, v]) => {
+      employees
-        const origVal = k === "jobid" ? (original.job?.id ?? original.jobid ?? original[k]) : original[k];
-        return String(fmt(k, origVal)) !== String(fmt(k, v)) ? `${k}: ${fmt(k, origVal)} → ${fmt(k, v)}` : null;
-      })
-      .filter(Boolean);
-
-    insertAuditTrail({
-      jobid: timeticket.job?.id ?? timeticket.jobid,
-      operation: AuditTrailMapping.timeticketupdated(
-        [original.employee.first_name, original.employee.last_name].filter(Boolean).join(" "),
-        original.date ? dayjs(original.date).format("YYYY-MM-DD") : "<<empty>>",
-        changed.length ? changed.join("; ") : "No changes"
-      )
     });
 
+    if (auditSummary.jobid) {
+      insertAuditTrail({
+        jobid: auditSummary.jobid,
+        operation: isEdit
+          ? AuditTrailMapping.timeticketupdated(auditSummary.employeeName, auditSummary.date, auditSummary.details)
+          : AuditTrailMapping.timeticketcreated(auditSummary.employeeName, auditSummary.date, auditSummary.details),
+        type: isEdit ? "timeticketupdated" : "timeticketcreated"
+      });
+    }
+
     // Refresh parent screens (Job Labor tab, etc.)
     if (timeTicketModal.actions.refetch) timeTicketModal.actions.refetch();
 

client/src/translations/en_us/common.json

@@ -122,7 +122,7 @@
         "billdeleted": "Bill with invoice number {{invoice_number}} deleted.",
         "billmarkforreexport": "Bill with invoice number {{invoice_number}} marked for re-export.",
         "billposted": "Bill with invoice number {{invoice_number}} posted.",
-        "billupdated": "Bill with invoice number {{invoice_number}} updated with the following details: {{values}}.",
+        "billupdated": "Bill with invoice number {{invoice_number}} updated with the following details: {{details}}.",
         "failedpayment": "Failed payment attempt.",
         "jobassignmentchange": "Employee {{name}} assigned to {{operation}}",
         "jobassignmentremoved": "Employee assignment removed for {{operation}}",
@@ -137,9 +137,9 @@
         "jobintake": "Job intake completed. Status set to {{status}}. Scheduled completion is {{scheduled_completion}}.",
         "jobinvoiced": "Job has been invoiced.",
         "jobioucreated": "IOU Created.",
-        "joblineupdate": "Job line {{line_desc}} updated.",
+        "joblineupdate": "Job line {{lineDescription}} updated with the following details: {{details}}.",
         "jobmanualcreate": "Job manually created.",
-        "jobmanuallineinsert": "Job line manually added with the following details: {{values}}.",
+        "jobmanuallineinsert": "Job line manually added with the following details: {{details}}.",
         "jobmodifylbradj": "Labor adjustments modified {{mod_lbr_ty}} / {{hours}}.",
         "jobnoteadded": "Note added to Job.",
         "jobnotedeleted": "Note deleted from Job.",
@@ -156,6 +156,7 @@
         "tasks_uncompleted": "Task '{{title}}' uncompleted by {{uncompletedBy}}",
         "tasks_undeleted": "Task '{{title}}' undeleted by {{undeletedBy}}",
         "tasks_updated": "Task '{{title}}' updated by {{updatedBy}}",
+        "timeticketcreated": "Time Ticket for {{employee}} on {{date}} created with the following details: {{details}}.",
         "timeticketupdated": "Time Ticket for {{employee}} on {{date}} updated with the following details: {{details}}"
       }
     },

client/src/translations/es/common.json

@@ -122,7 +122,6 @@
         "billdeleted": "",
         "billposted": "",
         "billmarkforreexport": "",
-        "billupdated": "",
         "failedpayment": "",
         "jobassignmentchange": "",
         "jobassignmentremoved": "",
@@ -137,9 +136,6 @@
         "jobintake": "",
         "jobinvoiced": "",
         "jobioucreated": "",
-        "joblineupdate": "",
-        "jobmanualcreate": "",
-        "jobmanuallineinsert": "",
         "jobmodifylbradj": "",
         "jobnoteadded": "",
         "jobnotedeleted": "",
@@ -155,8 +151,7 @@
         "tasks_deleted": "",
         "tasks_uncompleted": "",
         "tasks_undeleted": "",
-        "tasks_updated": "",
+        "tasks_updated": ""
-        "timeticketupdated": ""
       }
     },
     "billlines": {

client/src/translations/fr/common.json

@@ -122,7 +122,6 @@
         "billdeleted": "",
         "billmarkforreexport": "",
         "billposted": "",
-        "billupdated": "",
         "failedpayment": "",
         "jobassignmentchange": "",
         "jobassignmentremoved": "",
@@ -137,9 +136,6 @@
         "jobintake": "",
         "jobinvoiced": "",
         "jobioucreated": "",
-        "joblineupdate": "",
-        "jobmanualcreate": "",
-        "jobmanuallineinsert": "",
         "jobmodifylbradj": "",
         "jobnoteadded": "",
         "jobnotedeleted": "",
@@ -155,8 +151,7 @@
         "tasks_deleted": "",
         "tasks_uncompleted": "",
         "tasks_undeleted": "",
-        "tasks_updated": "",
+        "tasks_updated": ""
-        "timeticketupdated": ""
       }
     },
     "billlines": {

client/src/utils/AuditTrailMappings.js

@@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ const AuditTrailMapping = {
   billdeleted: (invoice_number) => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.billdeleted", { invoice_number }),
   billmarkforreexport: (invoice_number) => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.billmarkforreexport", { invoice_number }),
   billposted: (invoice_number) => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.billposted", { invoice_number }),
-  billupdated: (invoice_number, values) => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.billupdated", { invoice_number, values }),
+  billupdated: (invoice_number, details) => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.billupdated", { invoice_number, details }),
   jobassignmentchange: (operation, name) => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.jobassignmentchange", { operation, name }),
   jobassignmentremoved: (operation) => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.jobassignmentremoved", { operation }),
   jobchecklist: (type, inproduction, status) =>
@@ -26,9 +26,10 @@ const AuditTrailMapping = {
   jobinproductionchange: (inproduction) => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.jobinproductionchange", { inproduction }),
   jobinvoiced: () => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.jobinvoiced"),
   jobclosedwithbypass: () => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.jobclosedwithbypass"),
-  joblineupdate: (line_desc) => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.joblineupdate", { line_desc }),
+  joblineupdate: (lineDescription, details) =>
+    i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.joblineupdate", { details, lineDescription }),
   jobmanualcreate: () => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.jobmanualcreate"),
-  jobmanuallineinsert: (values) => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.jobmanuallineinsert", { values }),
+  jobmanuallineinsert: (details) => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.jobmanuallineinsert", { details }),
   jobmodifylbradj: ({ mod_lbr_ty, hours }) => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.jobmodifylbradj", { mod_lbr_ty, hours }),
   jobnoteadded: () => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.jobnoteadded"),
   jobnoteupdated: () => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.jobnoteupdated"),
@@ -76,7 +77,10 @@ const AuditTrailMapping = {
       title,
       uncompletedBy
     }),
-    timeticketupdated: (employee, date, details) => i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.timeticketupdated", { employee, date, details })
+  timeticketcreated: (employee, date, details) =>
+    i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.timeticketcreated", { employee, date, details }),
+  timeticketupdated: (employee, date, details) =>
+    i18n.t("audit_trail.messages.timeticketupdated", { employee, date, details })
 };
 
 export default AuditTrailMapping;

client/src/utils/auditTrailDetails.js

@@ -0,0 +1,186 @@
+import dayjs from "./day";
+
+const EMPTY_VALUE = "<<empty>>";
+const NO_CHANGES = "No changes";
+
+const BILL_LINE_KEYS = ["line_desc", "quantity", "actual_price", "actual_cost", "cost_center"];
+const JOB_LINE_SKIP_KEYS = new Set(["ah_detail_line", "prt_dsmk_p"]);
+const DATE_ONLY_KEYS = new Set(["date"]);
+const DATE_TIME_KEYS = new Set(["clockon", "clockoff"]);
+const CURRENCY_KEYS = new Set(["actual_price", "actual_cost", "act_price", "db_price", "rate"]);
+const HOUR_KEYS = new Set(["productivehrs", "actualhrs", "mod_lb_hrs"]);
+
+const isBlank = (value) => value == null || value === "";
+
+const isStructuredValue = (value) => value != null && typeof value === "object" && !dayjs.isDayjs?.(value);
+
+const formatDate = (value) => (isBlank(value) ? EMPTY_VALUE : dayjs(value).format("YYYY-MM-DD"));
+
+const formatDateTime = (value) => (isBlank(value) ? EMPTY_VALUE : dayjs(value).format("YYYY-MM-DD HH:mm"));
+
+const formatNumber = (value, fractionDigits) =>
+  typeof value === "number" ? value.toFixed(fractionDigits) : String(value);
+
+const compareValue = (key, value) => {
+  if (isBlank(value)) return EMPTY_VALUE;
+  if (DATE_TIME_KEYS.has(key)) return formatDateTime(value);
+  if (DATE_ONLY_KEYS.has(key)) return formatDate(value);
+  if (dayjs.isDayjs?.(value)) return formatDateTime(value);
+  return String(value);
+};
+
+const buildFieldChangeDetails = ({ keys, original = {}, updated = {}, displayValue, skippedKeys = new Set() }) =>
+  keys
+    .filter((key) => key !== "__typename" && !skippedKeys.has(key))
+    .filter((key) => !isStructuredValue(original[key]) && !isStructuredValue(updated[key]))
+    .map((key) => {
+      if (compareValue(key, original[key]) === compareValue(key, updated[key])) return null;
+      return `${key}: ${displayValue(key, original[key])} -> ${displayValue(key, updated[key])}`;
+    })
+    .filter(Boolean);
+
+const formatBillValue = (key, value) => {
+  if (isBlank(value)) return EMPTY_VALUE;
+  if (DATE_ONLY_KEYS.has(key)) return formatDate(value);
+  if (CURRENCY_KEYS.has(key)) return typeof value === "number" ? `$${value.toFixed(2)}` : String(value);
+  return String(value);
+};
+
+const formatJobLineValue = (key, value) => {
+  if (isBlank(value)) return EMPTY_VALUE;
+  if (CURRENCY_KEYS.has(key)) return typeof value === "number" ? `$${value.toFixed(2)}` : String(value);
+  if (HOUR_KEYS.has(key)) return formatNumber(value, 1);
+  return String(value);
+};
+
+const getEmployeeName = (employeeId, employees = [], fallbackEmployee) => {
+  if (
+    (employeeId == null || fallbackEmployee?.id === employeeId) &&
+    (fallbackEmployee?.first_name || fallbackEmployee?.last_name)
+  ) {
+    return [fallbackEmployee.first_name, fallbackEmployee.last_name].filter(Boolean).join(" ");
+  }
+
+  const employee = employees.find(({ id }) => id === employeeId);
+  if (employee) {
+    return [employee.first_name, employee.last_name].filter(Boolean).join(" ");
+  }
+
+  return employeeId ? String(employeeId) : EMPTY_VALUE;
+};
+
+const formatTimeTicketValue = (key, value, { employees = [], fallbackEmployee } = {}) => {
+  if (isBlank(value)) return EMPTY_VALUE;
+  if (key === "employeeid") return getEmployeeName(value, employees, fallbackEmployee);
+  if (DATE_TIME_KEYS.has(key)) return formatDateTime(value);
+  if (DATE_ONLY_KEYS.has(key)) return formatDate(value);
+  if (CURRENCY_KEYS.has(key)) return typeof value === "number" ? `$${value.toFixed(2)}` : String(value);
+  if (HOUR_KEYS.has(key)) return formatNumber(value, 1);
+  if (typeof value === "boolean") return value ? "true" : "false";
+  return String(value);
+};
+
+const buildBillLineSummary = (line) =>
+  BILL_LINE_KEYS.map((key) => `${key}: ${formatBillValue(key, line[key])}`).join(", ");
+
+export function buildBillUpdateAuditDetails({ originalBill = {}, bill = {}, billlines = [] }) {
+  const updatedBill = { ...bill, billlines };
+  const billKeys = Array.from(new Set([...Object.keys(originalBill), ...Object.keys(updatedBill)])).filter(
+    (key) => key !== "billlines"
+  );
+
+  const changed = buildFieldChangeDetails({
+    keys: billKeys,
+    original: originalBill,
+    updated: updatedBill,
+    displayValue: formatBillValue
+  });
+
+  const originalBillLines = originalBill.billlines ?? [];
+  const updatedBillLines = updatedBill.billlines ?? [];
+
+  const addedLines = updatedBillLines
+    .filter((line) => !line.id)
+    .map((line) => `+${line.line_desc || line.description || "new line"} (${buildBillLineSummary(line)})`);
+
+  const removedLines = originalBillLines
+    .filter((line) => !updatedBillLines.some((updatedLine) => updatedLine.id === line.id))
+    .map(
+      (line) => `-${line.line_desc || line.description || line.id || "removed line"} (${buildBillLineSummary(line)})`
+    );
+
+  const modifiedLines = updatedBillLines
+    .filter((line) => line.id)
+    .flatMap((line) => {
+      const originalLine = originalBillLines.find(({ id }) => id === line.id);
+      if (!originalLine) return [];
+
+      const lineChanges = buildFieldChangeDetails({
+        keys: BILL_LINE_KEYS,
+        original: originalLine,
+        updated: line,
+        displayValue: formatBillValue
+      });
+
+      if (!lineChanges.length) return [];
+
+      return [`${line.line_desc || line.description || line.id}: ${lineChanges.join("; ")}`];
+    });
+
+  if (addedLines.length) changed.push(`billlines added: ${addedLines.join(" | ")}`);
+  if (removedLines.length) changed.push(`billlines removed: ${removedLines.join(" | ")}`);
+  if (modifiedLines.length) changed.push(`billlines modified: ${modifiedLines.join(" | ")}`);
+
+  return changed.length ? changed.join("; ") : NO_CHANGES;
+}
+
+export function buildJobLineInsertAuditDetails(values = {}) {
+  const details = Object.entries(values)
+    .filter(([key, value]) => !JOB_LINE_SKIP_KEYS.has(key) && !isBlank(value))
+    .map(([key, value]) => `${key}: ${formatJobLineValue(key, value)}`);
+
+  return details.length ? details.join("; ") : NO_CHANGES;
+}
+
+export function buildJobLineUpdateAuditDetails({ originalLine = {}, values = {} }) {
+  const details = buildFieldChangeDetails({
+    keys: Object.keys(values),
+    original: originalLine,
+    updated: values,
+    displayValue: formatJobLineValue,
+    skippedKeys: JOB_LINE_SKIP_KEYS
+  });
+
+  return details.length ? details.join("; ") : NO_CHANGES;
+}
+
+export function buildTimeTicketAuditSummary({ originalTicket = {}, submittedValues = {}, employees = [] }) {
+  const normalizedOriginal = {
+    ...originalTicket,
+    jobid: originalTicket.job?.id ?? originalTicket.jobid ?? null
+  };
+
+  const details = buildFieldChangeDetails({
+    keys: Object.keys(submittedValues),
+    original: normalizedOriginal,
+    updated: submittedValues,
+    displayValue: (key, value) =>
+      formatTimeTicketValue(key, value, {
+        employees,
+        fallbackEmployee: key === "employeeid" ? normalizedOriginal.employee : null
+      })
+  });
+
+  const employeeName = getEmployeeName(
+    submittedValues.employeeid ?? normalizedOriginal.employeeid,
+    employees,
+    normalizedOriginal.employee
+  );
+
+  return {
+    date: formatDate(submittedValues.date ?? normalizedOriginal.date),
+    details: details.length ? details.join("; ") : NO_CHANGES,
+    employeeName,
+    jobid: submittedValues.jobid ?? normalizedOriginal.jobid ?? null
+  };
+}